Skip to main content
4 of 5
replaced http://meta.stackexchange.com/ with https://meta.stackexchange.com/

Flagging link-only answers

I once flagged two link-only answers, but since we're not StackOverflow, in terms of size/#users, I think we should rather strive to comment/edit the posts, so as to make them not link-only answers. This may seem odd, since there are questions in which people actually want a reference on a specific subject, like in these questions:

But I guess whenever the request is not for dataset/API/tool sources, and actually for explanations/examples on some topic, as these posts:

the answers should praise this rule of thumb discussed on meta.stackexchange. So, the idea is simply to either comment link-only answers, in order to ask the OP to improve their question, or simply suggest an edit.

Now, to leave a question here: what should actually be done for link-only answers? Are these suggestions enough/reasonable, or should we flag them anyway? Any further suggestions are surely much welcome.

Rubens
  • 4.1k
  • 10
  • 8