12
$\begingroup$

I was a part of the Big Data beta about a year ago and I was saddened when it didn't meet the qualifications to get out of Beta.

A few notes from the link above:

  1. We need to average at least 15 questions a day.
  2. We need to average 90% answered questions.
  3. Hand out votes like they are candy. We should have 150 users with 200+ reputation, 10 users with 2,000 reputation, and 5 users with 3,000 reputation. This is an area where we failed heavily on the big data beta.
  4. Answer questions that have already been answered. There should be 3 answers for every question, not just the one correct one.
  5. Keep coming back and encourage all of your friends to keep coming back. We should have 1500 visits per day. With Big Data we only managed 60/day.

There are a couple of checkpoints where Stack Exchange will pop in and decide whether or not to keep the beta going. I had originally thought we had 30 days to get things going, but we were shut down after 18 days. I've seen another beta shut down after just a few days, although I can't remember the name.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ So what happened to the questions and answers in this closed Big Data beta? I would like to take part but I'm also afraid that it eventually gets closed. I had a bad experience with one SE on AI earlier this year which got closed so quickly even before it had the chance to attract more people. $\endgroup$ – Franck Dernoncourt Jun 16 '14 at 19:17
  • $\begingroup$ If I remember right, you could download them for a few days after it closed. I missed the window, which bummed me out. $\endgroup$ – Steve Kallestad Jun 16 '14 at 22:30
  • $\begingroup$ Yeah I hear you, I am very averse to the deletion of user contents. Please support if you agree: When a beta SE gets closed, let the dump available on Area 51 $\endgroup$ – Franck Dernoncourt Jun 17 '14 at 18:03
12
$\begingroup$

I was a part of the Big Data beta about a year ago and I was saddened when it didn't meet the qualifications to get out of Beta.

I have been a part of 7+ betas so far of which a few were closed. It is always disappointing to see that happen. However, the decision to close a site that is a ghost town is much better than keeping it open and causing frustration to any people who may come across it in the future.

One other thing that I came to understand is that every beta is different. The metrics are variable, and are not applied as-is to every site. Various considerations such as engagement, moderation, commenting, and quality come into the picture; none of which can be easily given a number.

We need to average at least 15 questions a day.

During the beta, it is more important to create 4-5 good researched specific questions per day; than 15 mediocre ones. For the first few months, quality is paramount as it sets the tone for the site for the months to come.

We need to average 90% answered questions.

This is another parameter that varies depending on the community. In some cases, it is simply not possible to maintain very high ratios as experts of certain niches within a field may not be present. This doesn't seem to be a problem here; the current percentage of answered questions is 100%.

Keep coming back and encourage all of your friends to keep coming back. We should have 1500 visits per day. With Big Data we only managed 60/day.

This is something that requires attention and directed efforts to increase. The visit/day is very low. It deserves a separate post, though.

There are a couple of checkpoints where Stack Exchange will pop in and decide whether or not to keep the beta going. I had originally thought we had 30 days to get things going, but we were shut down after 18 days. I've seen another beta shut down after just a few days, although I can't remember the name.

The policy for the past year has been to have 1-2 week long private betas, after which the site is closed or made public. This site got an extended private beta and is one of the first this year to have that. The 30 day beta period has not been the policy for over a year now.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Very insightful! Thank you. $\endgroup$ – Steve Kallestad Jun 10 '14 at 13:22
3
$\begingroup$

Keep coming back and encourage all of your friends to keep coming back. We should have 1500 visits per day. With Big Data we only managed 60/day.

This is something that requires attention and directed efforts to increase. The visit/day is very low. It deserves a separate post, though.

My first guess here is, that those of us, who are active users of Stats.SE and Stackoverflow can try to redirect and target users from that sites to data science SE. Of course if they are answering relevant questions.

The problem is that most of SE users don't know about this resource yet.

And we should keep creating content, and Google will admit it very soon.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Hopefully someone from SE will see this and take note - there is no way to communicate with someone on SE other than posting a comment which would (or should) be considered spam. There should be a button on people's profile that says "recommend a beta site", which would send them at least a canned notification. $\endgroup$ – Steve Kallestad Jun 16 '14 at 18:01

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .